Evidence Synthesis: Systematic & Scoping Reviews for the University Park Campus: Collaborating Guide

Services for Systematic Reviews Outside of Medicine

Procedures for Collaborating with UPC Librarians

  • Expectations
    • These usually take from 8 months to 2 years (abbreviated timelines due to previous work and scoping vs systematic review)
    • Faculty Librarian is an Author
    • Librarian and/or Team complete Systematic Searching
      • Zotero
        • Training on issues in this process* (Librarian)
      • Covidence
        • Librarian will upload Zotero library to Covidence and apply settings for screening
        • Covidence will automatically de-duplicate resources
        • Covidence will manage all screening functions based on our settings (requiring two researchers for each screening step, and managing conflicts )
        • Covidence will auto-generate PRISMA chart as we move through the Process
    • Team will search and screen, and do most writing with exception of methods section (Librarian (s) writes methods section and develops charts)
    • Data extraction, quality assurance, results and discussion sections of writing (librarian does not usually participate in these steps- but can if subject expertise and time permits)
      • Qualtrics will be used for data extraction to be tailored to the research questions (due to Covidence being developed for RCTs and Medical trials)
  • Shared Drive
  • Schedule Day/Time meetings for 6 – 12 months out (cancel as needed)
    • Check calendar for cancellations
    • We will record and put URL to recording in meeting recording document
  • Librarian uploads systematic tracking sheet
  • Team will begin writing intro and lit review* (scoping or systematic may differ)
  • Once Systematic Searching is complete Librarian will train team on using Covidence SR software (https://www.covidence.org/) , make our project, and send invites to team- then upload Zotero library- web-based Covidence sign in with USC e-mail as institutional subscription
  • Team will screen for scoping review, (if project moves to systematic review- extract data and do quality assurance in Covidence) while Librarian writes methods section
  • Team writes results and discussion
  • Develop charts (librarian for methods charts- team for results charts)*
    • Template for the results chart
    • Covidence will automatically make PRISMA Chart
  • Librarian will provide publications chart to team*
    • Team decision on publication outlet
  • All will participate in final editing
  • Lead author will submit and converse with journal
  • Lead author will lead peer review and editing if accepted or submit to another journal
  • If any review team members of a project abandon the project or is unreachable, the remaining team members reserve the right to continue to complete the project and submit the manuscript. Authorship of all members is dependent on the participation throughout.