CORE 112: Types of Sources

Different Sources

Besides primary sources (novels, films, etc.), you will find other types of sources in library databases each offer a different perspective to the scholarly conversation. It's helpful to search in more than one database since each offers a different set of resources and search functions.

Critical Analysis: These types of sources make an argument and apply one or more critical theories to a text. For example: A literary criticism of a specific work

Research Study: Typically found in journals, these sources focus on the relationship and effects between ideas. For example: a study of the effects of gender bias in advertising media, an ethnographic study of a city, or a psychological study of adolescent sexual behavior

Theoretical / Introductory reference works: These types of sources can help you take a big picture look at movements, themes, theories, and other background information pertinent to the text you're writing about. This background information can lead to keywords, ideas, and connections you might not have discovered otherwise. It's an important step in the cyclical process of research. For example: if you're interested in writing about Blood Meridian by Cormac McCarthy you could look for introductory information on Westerns, war novels, other McCarthy novels, or nihilism.

Locating Sources

When looking for criticism, use advanced search features, to search by the work or author. Databases will often link articles on a particular work together. Less keywords are more when looking for criticism, try and think of the types of analysis or perspectives you would like to find for example: Modernism, Marxist, Queer Theory, Feminist, Race Theory, etc.

In MLA International Bibliography, for example, you can find these links at the bottom of the page:

Research studies and other journal articles that report on original research can be found by using keywords that describe the relationship you want more information about. For example if you are interested in the benefits and harms of gentrification you might try searching "Gentrification AND Displacement" as a specific harm of gentrification. Journal articles are narrow in focus and will not typically provide an overview on a topic.

Theoretical and introductory works provide broad overviews and definitions on movements, themes, theories, and other topics. To find these materials try searching broad singular terms.

Use the resources cited to get more specific, find other sources, and understand the general themes in a topic.

Loading

Activity

Using the Google Document template:

Before the session

  1. Click on the Core 112 activity template. Select "File" and then "Make a Copy" from the dropdown menu.
  2. Retitle and edit the copied document as you see fit for your specific Core 112 class.
  3. Double check your "Share" settings in the top right corner. You want anyone to be able to edit the document if they have the link. This is not the default setting, so you will need to change it. Copy the shareable link. Shorten the URL using a URL shortener like Bit.ly . This is the link you'll share with the class.

During the session

  1. Introduce basic searching skills including how to find the full text of documents
  2. Provide the link to students for the Core 112 activity
  3. Students complete the activity with guidance and help on their individual topics
  4. Come back together as a class and discuss what students found

Modification: Use the same questions in a Google Form and have students complete the activity as a homework assignment

Possible discussion questions:

  • How do these sources talk to each other?
  • What further perspectives do they refer to?
  • How can we tell if the sources we find are central to the scholarly conversation?

Information Literacy Outcomes

  • Identify the contribution that particular information sources make within an ongoing conversation
  • Describe the way that systems privilege some perspectives and present barriers to others